Nevada is the darkly comedic story of maria griffiths, a young trans woman. A commenter recently asked if this book was protransition. The main character jess goldberg, is always on the moveeither trying to find a new spot to maybe fit in, or more likely. It follows the story of jess, a heshe later butch, as the story progresses and she hates herself less from a working class jewish family. The stone butch blues study guide contains a comprehensive summary and analysis of stone butch blues by leslie feinberg. She eloquently writes what she believes to be the true meaning of love.
And a challenge to all of us to think more actively and explicitly about deconstructing and reconstructing cultures, not only with regard to their handling of matters of sexidentity but more generally. Stone butch blues is a snapshot of an era before concepts like transgender and gender nonconforming were commonly articulated, let alone recognized or accepted. Mar 29, 2018 for stone butch blues is a seminal title in the queer literary canon. Its a devastating and powerful book, and refuses to step away from how difficult life was then, and how for many people it still is. The language used for butch identities isnt created by butch people, or for them.
Stone butch blues is modestly the story of a person who, because of the callousness of our society, does not fit into the social norm. But it looks like someone might be trying a film adaptation nonetheless. Stone butch blues is a 1993 semiautobiographical novel by transgender activist leslie feinberg. A stone butch has every reason to feel the blues in leslie feinbergs criticallyacclaimed, awardwinning novel stone butch blues. The novel tells of what a difficult and often violent life jess has had to endure, for being different and not fitting into the mold of conventional binary gender system.
How so many others are forced for their physical and mental safety to navigate workplaces, cities, domestic spaces. It may be advisable to prepare students with discussions on sexuality and sexual difference, especially as concerns butchfemme relationships. Jess, the narrator of stone butch blues, spends the space of the novel looking for a way to authentically exist in the world at large. The story follows the life of the incredibly resilient jess goldberg as. Proposed stone butch blues film raises questions about authorial. Stone butch blues, leslie feinberg s 1993 first novel, is widely considered in and outside the u. The novel involves a great deal of union organizing and discusses the treatment of workingclass people. In chapter 16 of the novel, the reader learns about jessys new love interest, annie. Dec 18, 2014 stone butch blues lays out all the pain of difference, the limited places and communities of safety and the intensity of loneliness separating them in time and space. Leslie feinberg, stone butch blues polyphonic world. Stone butch blues, leslie feinbergs 1993 first novel, is widely considered in and outside the u. Butch blues to transformative moments of recognition. After reading this i was able to accept my own masculinity and life has only been up since then.
Jess is aware from a young age that she is different from other girls, and often. Blues creates such a real and violent world filled with the emotional truth that. Stone butch blues begins to develop that language in a. A stone butch blues movie betrays leslie feinbergs legacy. The achievement of feinbergs awardwinning novel is not that it is the first novel to tell the story of a transgendered person, but that it is the first to embrace transgendered as an identity. In all this searching, though, i never read stone butch blues, by leslie feinberg. She has her first sexual encounter since her hormone change. Leslie feinbergs stone butch blues is a great novel.
Stone butch blues was a gateway for me to understanding love. For stone butch blues is a seminal title in the queer literary canon. The story highlights gender identity, exploration, and transformation. Stone butch blues is a novel written by the revolutionary communist leslie feinberg about life as a butch lesbian in 1970s america. One day jess finds ed at her home dressed for a fine occasion. Set in 1970s new york, stone butch blues tells the story of jess goldberg, a bluecollar worker and a union activist navigating community, survival, and shifting notions of sexuality and gender transition. I marvel at how much difference there was for people like us over the past ten years. Queer literary classic stone butch blues is being turned. I saw the cover in passing, but no one had told me about it. Stone butch blues is a phenomenal read for those who would enjoy reading about transsexual fiction and inequality issues such as gay rights.
Stone butch blues, a semiautobiographical novel about a butch named. Feinberg was the first theorist to advance a marxist concept of transgender liberation. Stone butch blues is also a novel of the working class. Mar 07, 2018 stone butch blues, a semiautobiographical novel about a butch named jess goldberg who comes of age in the 1960s and has a complex relationship with gender, still holds great importance in the literary world, in the lesbian community and in the lgbtq community as a whole 20 years after the novels publication and four years after. I dont believe any movie can be made true to the intention of the book. Nov 17, 2014 stone butch blues was the heartbreaking holy grail of butch perspective. Stone butch blues is the latest literary work adapted into. Stone butch blues lays out all the pain of difference, the limited places and communities of safety and the intensity of loneliness separating them in time and space.
Stone butch blues summary and study guide supersummary. The painful history lessons of stone butch blues eesti lgbt uhing. Kendall fuller to the outside big question road which team jerseys from china. The story takes you through her traumatic experiences as a child, to growing up in the bars, to finding an identity that put her in tremendous. Full text of stone butch blues 20th anniversary author. Stone butch blues is a story about the life and identity of a butch lesbian by the name of jess goldberg. The definition of stone butch blues essay 1680 words. That said, stone butch blues is an important reminder that there is a continuum from psychic discomfort to psychic abuse to physical abuse. Jess talks about the need for butch words to talk about butch feelings pg. Dont tell me youre honoring me by saying you can tell this story. Stone butch blues traces a propulsive journey, powerfully evoking history and. Proposed stone butch blues film raises questions about.
Stone butch blues was the heartbreaking holy grail of butch perspective. Over time, goldberg becomes a labor activist, moves to new york city, and eventually decides to transition to male. Stone butch blues follows the story of jess goldberg. Once you get to know the protagonist, jess, shell never leave your heart. Stone butch blues is a book that touched my heart very deeply. Stone butch blues book by leslie feinberg thriftbooks. Goodreads members who liked stone butch blues also liked. Not only does she dress, act and think like a man, she fundamentally believes that she is a man. Dont tell me youre honoring me by saying you can tell this story better than i did. The news of the stone butch blues movie came out when the production company, 11b productions posted a casting call. The best book for 2018 is 25 years old the new york times. Click below to download the full study guide for stone butch blues. It is the fictional story of a young woman named jess goldberg and the many problems she faces growing up as a butch in the late1960s.
This study guide consists of approximately 64 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of stone butch blues. Stone butch blues by leslie feinberg chapters 12 duration. Nov 02, 2012 imagine being asked on a daily basis what your gender was. A commonly asked questioned for our main character jessy. Because jessy did not abide by societys idea of a heteronormative appearance for a young female adolescent i. Stone butch blues follows protagonist, jess goldberg, a gender. A large segment is devoted to the tribulations of being a stone butch person, and the experience of being a lesbian while identifying with masculine traits. Full text of stone butch blues 20th anniversary author edition see other formats. Nov 25, 2014 leslie feinberg, a writer and activist whose 1993 novel, stone butch blues, is considered a landmark in the contemporary literature of gender complexity, died on nov. Jess goldbergs story and the struggle and oppression that she went through.
Stone butch blues is the latest literary work adapted. Her knowledge and courage to be her own person are very admirable traits for someone at such a young age as her. Aug 04, 2017 jess talks about the need for butch words to talk about butch feelings pg. Stone butch blues was a gripping and consistently sad account of the life of a tough yet sensitive butch and i learned quite a bit from it. Because this project is categorized as in development, the data is only available on imdbpro and is subject to change. Stone butch blues, a semiautobiographical novel about a butch named jess goldberg who comes of age in the 1960s and has a complex relationship with gender, still holds great importance in the literary world, in the lesbian community and in the lgbtq community as a whole 20 years after the novels publication and four years after. Stone butch blues by leslie feinberg project myopia.
The chemistry between annie and jessy is obvious from the moment they meet in. The main character jess goldberg, is always on the moveeither trying. From her earliest memories, jess goldberg knew she was painfully different from other girls. Leslie feinberg, a writer and activist whose 1993 novel, stone butch blues, is considered a landmark in the contemporary literature of gender complexity, died on nov. Oct 12, 2015 stone butch blues is a book that touched my heart very deeply. Jul 19, 2017 leslie feinberg stone butch blues is the story of jess goldberg, a stone butch lesbian. Leslie feinberg stone butch blues is the story of jess goldberg, a stone butch lesbian. This sounds insane to say now, after weve survived the entire story arc of. In march of 1993, transgender activist leslie feinberg published a coming of age novel titled stone butch blues. The term stone butch was popularized by leslie feinberg in her 1993 novel stone butch blues, which describes the protagonists explorations of the lesbian community. Stone butch blues identity, gender, and mental health. I was buried under layers of shame and self hatred but this story taught me that we had a history and we deserved to be. Stone butch blues tells the story of jess goldberg, a baby butch growing into a new identity in defiance of the horrific institutional violence of. Apr 30, 2015 in march of 1993, transgender activist leslie feinberg published a coming of age novel titled stone butch blues.
Stone butch blues is a 1993 semiautobiographical novel by writer and activist leslie feinberg. She is happy wearing her roy rogers outfit, even in temple. Leslie feinbergs stone butch blues is a great novel everyone. Stone butch blues begins to develop that language in a way that includes all conceptions of the term butch. Nov 24, 2014 stone butch blues tells the story of jess goldberg, a baby butch growing into a new identity in defiance of the horrific institutional violence of prestonewall america. I bring it up every now and again because its part of my knowledge of the lesbian and ftm experience.
One is forced to recognize the violence inflicted on those who do not fit stereotypes of heterosexual, malefemale divisions. Nov 12, 2012 in chapter 16 of the novel, the reader learns about jessys new love interest, annie. Stone butch blues follows the story of jess goldberg, a workingclass butch lesbian who comes of age in the 1950s buffalo butch femme lesbian bar scene. After she is raped on campus by members of the football. Queer literary classic stone butch blues is being turned into.
Stone butch blues traces a propulsive journey, powerfully evoking history and politics while portraying this internationally acclaimed novel looks at the world through the eyes of jess goldberg, a masculine girl growing up in the ozzie and harriet mccarthy era and coming out as a young butch lesbian in the prestonewall gay drag bars of a. The narrative follows the life of jess goldberg, who grows up in a working class area of upstate new york in the 1940s to 1950s. Jess definitely had to walk a difficult path in life as was prophecized early on by her neighbors and caretakers. Stone butch blues both walks achingly alone and tells the sweet story of connecting to a society in which djhqf\ehfrphvsrvvleohhlqehujv hvvzlwqhvvhv the vast criminality of homophobia, the tenderness and the wildness of love, and the tiny, massive vitalities of friendship, work, and political community. Full text of stone butch blues 20th anniversary author edition. Stone butch blues follows the story of jess goldberg, a workingclass butch lesbian who comes of age in the 1950s buffalo butchfemme lesbian bar scene. It is also a great read for those who enjoy reading about the importance of keeping ones true identity in a society where laws, rules and standards are forced onto the people. The entirety of the novel revolves around the butchfemme subculture. Find books like stone butch blues from the worlds largest community of readers. Much of it takes place in factories in buffalo, ny. Jess goldberg grows up in buffalo, new york, as jewish girl at a time when open antisemitism is pervasive. Sold by the hundreds of thousands of copies and also passed from handtohand inside. As it turns out, no ones quite sure if 11b has the rights to the novel or not. Stone butch blues, to me, is the greatest, most important queer novel in the world, because it does not only offer an insular experience of difference.
887 1410 769 104 1221 1044 1473 1111 1229 1047 1053 1473 1002 365 82 1157 1159 301 135 1449 1417 200 1145 315 165 258 1136 1462 1494 1513 715 1054 249 1371 1290 567 364 1304 1086 64 1166 777 653 142